Malheur Experiment Station
Oregon State University
Information for Sustainable Agriculture


1999 CEREAL GRAIN VARIETY TRIALS

Eric P. Eldredge, Russ S. Karow, Clinton C. Shock, Ernie Marx, and Lamont Saunders

Malheur Experiment Station,

Oregon State University

Ontario, Oregon

Introduction

Cereal grain varieties were evaluated using furrow irrigation, typical of crop production in Malheur County. The trials included varieties that are in development, newly released, or commercially available. Information from these trials helps local growers learn the performance of new varieties in comparison to standard varieties. Cereal breeders gain site-specific performance information for advanced lines and new releases. Four cereal grain variety trials were conducted at the Malheur Experiment Station in the 1998-1999 crop year, as one of the OSU statewide cereal variety testing locations. The trials were a winter and a spring barley trial and a winter and a spring wheat and triticale trial. In addition, several planting rates, seed treatments, and variety combinations were planted for spring and fall planted wheat.

Methods

The grain trials followed sweet corn; the cornstalks were flailed, and the field was disked. The field was deep ripped, plowed, and groundhogged to prepare the seedbed. No preplant fertilizer was applied. The field was corrugated into 60-in beds and measured and marked for plots. All trials were planted using randomized complete block designs with three replications. Each plot was planted on a 60-in wide bed with seven rows spaced 6 in apart on the bed. Plot length was 20 ft, with 3.5-ft alleys cut between tiers of plots before harvest.

Winter Wheat, Triticale, and Barley Variety Trials. Winter grain trials were planted November 5, at a standard rate of 30 seeds/ft2. All seed was treated with fungicide and Gaucho insecticide. The Winter Barley Trial included four 6-row feed types and two dual use feed or malting 6-row varieties. The Winter Wheat and Triticale Trial included 21 soft white varieties, 5 club wheats, 1 hard red wheat, 2 hard white winter wheats, 1 durum wheat and 1 triticale.

Spring Wheat, Triticale, and Barley Variety Trials. The spring barley and spring wheat trials were planted March 16, 1999, in the same field beside the winter trials. The standard seeding rate was 30 seeds/ft2. All seed was treated with fungicide and Gaucho insecticide. The Spring Barley Trial included 6 feed-barleys, 4 malting barleys, and 6 lines being tested for malting potential. The Spring Wheat and Triticale Variety Trial included 17 soft white types, 5 hard white wheats, 5 hard red spring wheats, 1 triticale, and 1 unspecified market class.

Wheat Planting Rate, Variety Mixture and Seed Treatment Trials. Several planting rates, seed treatments, and variety combinations were tested for selected varieties of spring and fall planted wheat. Stephens winter wheat was planted at 20, 30, and 40 seeds per square foot (104, 156, and 207 lb/acre) with Gaucho fungicide. Stephens was planted also without Gaucho. Stepens was compared with Madsen and with a 1-1 mixture of Stephens and Madsen. Penawawa spring wheat was planted at 20, 30, and 40 seeds per square foot (88, 135, and 177 lb/acre) with Gaucho fungicide. Alpowa spring wheat was treated with Gaucho, no Gaucho, and a Novartis experimental seed treatment.

Soil sampling March 3 found 66 lb N/acre in the top 2 ft of soil in the spring grain trial area, pH 7.7, 1.1 percent organic matter, and 18 ppm extractable phosphorus. Soil sampling March 3, 1999, found 76 lb N/acre in the top 2 ft of soil in the winter grain trial area. Nitrogen fertilizer, in the form of urea prills, was broadcast March 9 at 74 lb N/acre on the spring grains and 92 lb N/acre on the winter grains. The grain trials were furrow irrigated on April 28, June 1, June 15, and June 29.

All the trials were harvested July 22, and the grain from each plot was bagged and tagged. Entries in all trial were evaluated for yield, test weight, protein percentage, thousand kernel weight, date of 50 percent heading, and plant height at maturity at the OSU Department of Crop and Soil Science Hyslop Farm, Corvallis, and the results were tabulated and posted at www.css.orst.edu/cereals.

Results

Winter Barley Variety Trial. Winter barley yields may have been reduced by the late planting date and by dry winter weather causing slow seedling development and thin stands in spring, along with dry, cool, windy weather in spring (Table 1). No disease or insect problems developed, and no lodging occurred in any variety. The winter barley variety ORW10 had severe feeding damage from redwing blackbirds in mid-June. Scio had the highest yield and the lowest test weight, but the performance differences were not statistically significant.

Spring Barley Variety Trial. Variety yields ranged from 5,537 lb/acre for Xena, a two-row feed type, to 3,502 lb/acre for Bancroft, a two row malting type (Table 2). Test weights ranged from 57.1 lb/bu for MT920073 to 53.4 lb/bu for Tango. Protein content ranged from 13.4 percent for Orca to 10 percent for Tango. Xena and WA9504-94 were the earliest spring barleys, with 50 percent heading at May 28, while Baronesse and Bancroft were the latest, reaching 50 percent heading 3 weeks later on June 21. Lodging did not occur.

The Winter Wheat and Triticale Variety Trial. Yield ranged from 129 bu/acre for Hiller to 70 bu/acre for Gene (Table 3). Test weight ranged from 60.6 lb/bu for OR939515 to 50.2 lb/bu for Rod. Protein content ranged from 10.7 percent for Stephens, OR939526, and Rod to 9.6 percent for OR908387 and Quantum 7817. Heading was delayed by prolonged cool weather in spring this year, with 50 percent heading dates ranging from June 1 for the triticale variety Bogo to June 17 for Coda. Plant height ranged from 44 in for ID86-10420A down to 33 in for Gene. No varieties lodged in this trial.

The Spring Wheat and Triticale Variety Trial. Yields of soft white spring wheats ranged from 86 bu/acre for IDO526 to 57 bu/acre for WPB BZ 692-108 (Table 4). Test weight of the soft white spring wheat varieties ranged from 64.8 lb/bu for Alpowa to 60.7 lb/bu for Treasure. Soft white protein content ranged from 11.4 percent for Whitebird to 8.2 percent for Wawawai. Date of 50 percent heading ranged from May 30 for Yecora Rojo to June 6 for WA7850, Pomerelle, and Treasure. Plant height ranged from 44 in for the triticale variety M94-4393 to 22 in for Yecora Rojo. Among the soft white wheats, plant height ranged from 36 inches for OR942889 to 28 inches for Alpowa and WPB BZ 692-108. Lodging was not observed in this trial.

Wheat Planting Rate, Variety Mixtures, and Seed Treatment Trials. A blend of Madsen and Stephens yielded 127 bu/acre, similar to the yield of the average of the two varieties planted alone (Table 5). Stephens yielded 126 bu/acre when planted at the standard rate of 30 seeds/ft2 (156 lb/acre), 130 bu/acre when planted at the rate of 40 seed/ft2 (207 lb/acre), and 106 bu/acre when planted at the rate of 20 seed/ft2 (104 lb/acre).

Alpowa spring wheat treated with an experimental seed treatment from Novartis yielded 40 bu/acre, compared to 61 bu/acre when treated with Gaucho and 59 bu/acre when treated with fungicide alone (Table 6). Penewawa yielded 70 bu/acre when planted at the standard rate of 30 seed/ft2 (135 lb/acre), compared to 59 bu/acre at 40 seed/ft2 (177 lb/acre), and 58 bu/acre at 20 seed/ft2 (88 lb/acre).

Table 1. Winter barley yield, test weight, percent protein, date of 50 percent heading and plant height at maturity, Malheur Experiment Station, Oregon State University, Ontario, Oregon, 1999.

Variety Market class Yield Test weight Protein 50 percent heading Plant height
    lb/acre lb/bu % DOY1 in
Scio 6RF 4,437 51.9 11.8 150 36
ORW11 6RF/M 3,990 53.9 12.1 149 39
Kold 6RF 3,409 53.4 13.1 149 37
OR1957369 6RF 2,376 53.3 12.0 151 36
ORW10 6RF/M 2,333 53.2 14.5 151 39
Strider 6RF 2,015 53.2 11.3 145 37
Mean   3,093 53.2 12.5 150 37.5
LSD (0.05)   NS NS 1.0 NS 2.4

1DOY, day of the year starting with January 1 = 1.

Table 2. Spring barley yield, test weight, protein percentage, 50 percent heading date, and plant height at maturity, Malheur Experiment Station, Oregon State University, Ontario, Oregon, 1999.

Variety Market class Yield Test weight Protein Heading date Height
    lb/acre lb/bu % DOY1 in
BCD 22 2RF/M 4,767 56.0 11.6 170 22
Orca 2RF 4,500 55.1 13.4 167 34
BCD 12 2RF/M 4,410 54.1 10.9 171 23
BCD 47 2RF/M 4,404 56.4 11.3 170 23
Xena (BZ594-19) 2RF 5,537 56.9 10.2 148 31
Idagold 2RF 5,410 55.9 10.3 168 24
Baronesse 2RF 5,261 56.6 10.3 172 30
Chinook 2RM 5,186 56.6 12.4 158 31
C-32 2RM 4,898 55.9 11.0 170 24
Galena 2RM 4,501 54.9 11.5 169 27
Bancroft 2RM 3,502 55.9 12.8 172 30
Tango 6RF 5,080 53.4 10.0 166 33
Steptoe 6RF 4,516 54.0 10.3 167 32
MT LB30 2RF/M 5,385 56.7 12.0 164 28
WA9504-94 2RF/M 5,239 55.5 11.1 148 27
MT920073 2RF/M 5,103 57.1 11.9 165 29
Mean    4,856 55.7 11.3 165 28
LSD (0.05)    ns 1.0 1.8 na na

1DOY, day of the year starting with January 1 = 1.

Table 3. Winter wheat and triticale yield, test weight, protein percentage, date of 50 percent heading, and plant height at maturity, Malheur Experiment Station, Oregon State University, Ontario, Oregon, 1999.

Variety Market class Yield Test weight Protein Heading date Height
    bu/acre lb/bu % DOY1 in
MacVicar  SW 126 56.2 10.3 157 38
Stephens  SW 126 58.6 10.2 155 37
ID10085-5  SW 125 59.1 10.1 156 42
OR908387  SW 121 59.8 9.6 157 37
Madsen  SW 120 56.5 10.3 157 37
OR939526 SW 119 54.0 10.7 156 38
OR939515  SW 117 60.6 10.1 157 40
Malcolm SW 115 57.2 10.4 157 39
OR939528 SW 114 58.4 10.0 157 39
Rod  SW 112 50.2 10.7 161 37
Weatherford  SW 112 57.9 10.2 158 36
OR3971244 SW 110 59.3 9.7 157 36
ID86-10420A  SW 108 58.0 10.1 158 44
Foote  SW 102 59.6 10.3 157 38
Quantum 7817 SW 101 58.8 9.6 157 41
Hybritech 1021 SW 73 55.1 9.8 157 36
Gene  SW 70 57.2 10.3 156 33
Hiller  Club 129 57.7 9.4 157 36
Rely  Club 117 58.9 10.1 158 39
Coda  Club 107 62.1 9.7 168 37
Temple  Club 107 61.2 10.6 156 37
Rohde  Club 103 59.5 10.5 157 36
ID467 HR 114 58.9 11.4 156 39
OR943575 HW 111 58.4 10.4 160 38
Ivory  HW 105 61.2 10.4 155 38
Connie  Durum 55 60.1 11.1 156 35
Bogo Triticale 138 57.5 8.6 152 42
Mean    110 58.2 10.2 157 38
LSD (0.05)    19 3.7 0.9 na na

1DOY, day of the year starting with January 1 = 1.

Table 4. Spring wheat and triticale yield, test weight, protein percentage, date of 50 percent heading, and plant height, Malheur Experiment Station, Oregon State University, Ontario, Oregon, 1999.

Variety  Market class Yield  Test weight Protein Heading date Height
    bu/acre lb/bu % DOY1 in
IDO526 SW 86 63.6 8.8 154 31
WA7850 SW 85 63.4 9.1 157 30
Pomerelle SW 83 61.0 8.9 157 30
IDO506 SW 83 62.0 8.9 155 32
Whitebird SW 81 63.8 11.4 155 34
Wawawai SW 78 62.7 8.2 155 34
OR942845 SW 77 63.5 10.4 155 31
IDO525 SW 74 63.4 8.8 154 32
Treasure SW 72 60.7 9.0 157 31
Penawawa  SW 70 63.7 9.2 156 31
OR942889 SW 69 65.0 9.4 153 36
Alpowa  SW 61 64.8 9.0 155 28
WPB BZ 692-108 SW 57 64.6 12.1 155 28
WPB936 HRS 82 64.1 8.9 153 27
Scarlet HRS 73 64.1 11.8 155 33
Jefferson HRS 67 64.6 11.0 152 32
WPB BZ 992-322 HRS 62 63.6 10.3 153 30
Yecora Rojo HRS 53 66.1 11.2 150 22
IDO377S HW 83 65.4 10.9 155 33
IDO533 HW 77 64.8 10.7 154 33
ML455 HW 76 64.6 10.2 155 31
IDO523 HW 61 64.6 9.8 154 31
OR4870453 (Winsome) HW 51 64.3 10.0 156 28
OR4920307   66 64.5 10.4 155 30
M94-4393 Triticale 49 57.2 10.4 154 44
Mean    71 63.6 10.0 155 31
LSD (0.05)    26 1.5 1.3 NA NA

1DOY, day of the year starting with January 1 = 1.

Table 5. Winter wheat seeding rates, blended varieties, and seed treatments, Malheur Experiment Station, Oregon State University, Ontario, Oregon, 1999.
Variety Market class Yield Test weight Protein Heading date Height
    bu/acre lb/bu % DOY1 in
Madsen  SW 120 56.5 10.3 157 37
Madsen+Stephens SW 127 59.9 10.0 157 37
Stephens, 156 lb/acre SW 126 58.6 10.2 155 37
Stephens, 104 lb/acre SW 106 55.9 10.7 156 35
Stephens, 207 lb/acre SW 130 58.1 10.7 155 36
Stephens - no Gaucho SW 111 59.0 10.2 155 36
Mean   120 58.0 10.4 156 36
LSD (0.05)   19 NS NS na na

1DOY, day of the year starting with January 1 = 1.

Table 6. Spring wheat seeding rates and seed treatments, Malheur Experiment Station, Oregon State University, Ontario, Oregon, 1999.
Variety Market class Yield Test weight Protein Heading date Height
    bu/acre lb/bu % DOY1 in
Alpowa (Novartis) SW 40 64.4 8.7 156 28
Alpowa (Gaucho) SW 61 64.8 9.0 155 28
Alpowa (no Gaucho) SW 59 64.4 9.1 155 30
Penawawa, 177 lb/acre SW 59 63.7 9.0 155 29
Penawawa, 135 lb/acre SW 70 63.7 9.2 156 31
Penawawa, 88 lb/acre SW 58 63.8 8.9 156 29
Mean   58 64.1 9.0 156 29
LSD (0.05)   26 NS NS NA NA

1DOY, day of the year starting with January 1 = 1.

Home Crops Weather Potato Blight Water Quality Irrigation Weeds Search

MES Publications, MES Notice of events, Vegetation,Malheur County, Leslie Gulch,Succor Creek,Owyhee River,Local wildlife,Strawberry Mountain, Eagle Caps

For additional information about the Malheur Agricultural Experiment Station, please send an e-mail request to:
Dr. Clinton C. Shock
Clinton.Shock@oregonstate.edu


Malheur Agricultural Experiment Station

595 Onion Avenue
Ontario, OR 97914
(541) 889-2174

FAX (541) 889-7831
 
Malheur Experiment Station Web Site Purpose and Policy OSU Home Page OSU disclaimer

Last updated  Tuesday July 30, 2002 .