Malheur Experiment Station
Oregon State University
Information for Sustainable Agriculture


Potato Seed Piece Fungicide/Insecticide Treatments, Malheur County, 1999

Lynn Jensen

Malheur County Extension Service

Oregon State University

Ontario, Oregon

Introduction

Fungicide treatments commonly are used on potato seed. There is no current information on the efficacy of these treatments under Treasure Valley environmental conditions. Growers also were seeking information about a seed treatment which had not been in common use in this area for many years. In cooperation with two local growers, two seed piece treatment trials were initiated, one on Shepody and the other on Russet Burbank potatoes.

Materials and Methods

The Shepody trial was established on the Iida Farm near Ontario, and the Russet Burbank trial on Peterson Farms near Owyhee Junction. A portion of the grower's field was blocked off and hand planted. The Shepody seed was supplied by Simplot, the Russet Burbank seed from Hartman Farms. All seed of each variety was from the same seed lot.

The Shepody field was hand planted by leveling the fall bedded ground with a tractor mounted shovel, dropping the seed along the bottom of the bed, hilling up with tractor mounted shovels, then finishing the hilling process with hand shovels. This process dried out the soil so that the plots had to be irrigated in order to have enough moisture for adequate growth. Water was applied by furrow irrigation 7 days after planting.

The Russet Burbank trial was hand planted into fall bedded ground by opening the bed with a trenching shovel, dropping the seed to the proper depth, and pulling the shovel out, leaving the soil mostly undisturbed. The plots had adequate moisture for emergence and early growth without irrigation.

The seed was hand cut into approximately 2.0-oz pieces. The seed treatments were applied by putting the cut seed and the fungicide in a plastic bag and mixing the seed with the treatment. The Blocker treatment was applied to the Shepody potatoes by spraying the liquid down the planted furrow prior to covering the seed. The spray volume was 27.4 gpa and the spray was allowed to dry before the seed was covered.

Each plot in both trials was 50 ft long by one row wide. The trial was a randomized complete block design with four replications. The Shepody trial was planted on April 14-15 and the Russet Burbank trial was planted on April 28-29. Planting depth was 6-8 inches below the top of the hill, and the seed was spaced 12 inches apart. Plant emergence and early growth were measured. Rhizoctonia was measured on July 23 for Russet Burbank and September 2 for Shepody. The potatoes were hand dug and graded. Ten plants per plot were evaluated to determine the amount and severity of rhizoctonia infection.

Results – Shepody

Stand counts and plant vigor measurements were taken on May 25. There were no differences in any treatments at that time. Plant height was measured on five plants in each plot on June 4 (Table 1). The plants treated with the Blocker alone were significantly shorter than the other treatments. The plants treated with Tops MZ were significantly taller than either the Maxim or Tops 5.0 treatments.

The trial was harvested on September 2. Stems from 10 plants were rated for rhizoctonia infection. Lesions were scored as mild or severe (Table 2). The untreated check had significantly more infected stems than any of the treatments. Blocker alone had significantly more infected stems than the other treatments except Tops 5.0 and Tops MZ. Maxim had the highest percentage of rhizoctonia-free stems. Adding Blocker to Tops MZ increased the number of disease-free stems substantially, even though the number wasn't different statistically. Adding Blocker to Maxim did not decrease rhizoctonia infections. Maxim had the lowest number of severe lesions. Tops 5.0 and Blocker had a significantly higher amount of lesions than Maxim. There was no difference in stem numbers (Table 3).

Since Shepody potato processing contracts are based on total yield minus soil, rot, and undersized tubers, only total yield was measured. Total yield from the untreated check was significantly less than all other treatments except Blocker (Table 4). Blocker had significantly less in total yield than Maxim and Tops MZ + Blocker. Tops MZ + Blocker was not significantly better than the Tops MZ treatment. The treatments of Maxim plus the at-planting insecticide treatments (API – 1.5 DS, 1.7 DS) did not increase yield. Insect counts were made during the growing season, but insect populations were very low in all of the treatments, and counts were not significantly different.

Results – Russet Burbank

The Russet Burbank trial included Tops 5.0, Tops MZ, Maxim, and the at-planting insecticide (API) added to Maxim at two rates. Blocker was not included in this trial. Emergence was delayed significantly by the Tops MZ treatment. Plant height was also less, though not significant, when measured on June 4, and there was a tendency to have reduced stem numbers with this treatment (Table 5).

Five plants per plot were harvested on July 23 (Table 6). Tops MZ had significantly fewer tuber numbers than Maxim + API 1.5 at the 90 percent confidence level. There were no significant differences in total tuber weight between treatments. There were highly significant differences between all of the treatments and the check for stems infected with severe Rhizoctonia. Severe rhizoctonia lesions were defined as lesions that had covered half the diameter of the stem. Maxim had significantly fewer severe lesions than Tops MZ. There were no differences in any of the treatments when both mild and severe lesions were considered.

Forty feet of row in each plot was harvested on October 1, graded, and weighed. There were no statistical differences in the treatments regarding yield (Table 7), but some trends seem apparent. Tops MZ had more large potatoes (>12 oz) but fewer small potatoes. One possible explanation is that rhizoctonia may have reduced the number of tubers enough to allow those that did survive to increase to a larger size. The main treatments with less rhizoctonia had smaller yields in the >12 oz category, probably because increased tuber numbers kept the tubers from sizing into the larger group. This is reflected in the higher yields in the 8–12 oz and 4–7.9 oz categories for Maxim.

Aphid counts were taken during the growing season, but the populations were so low that no determinations could be made on the efficacy of the planting insecticide seed treatments.

Conclusions

Blocker inhibited Shepody foliage growth early in the season. All of the seed treatments significantly increased yields of Shepody over the untreated check. Maxim and Tops MZ + Blocker both yielded significantly higher than Blocker applied alone on Shepody. Maxim was the best treatment for controlling severe rhizoctonia in both Shepody and Russet Burbank.

All of the seed treatments on Russet Burbank were better than the untreated check. The Maxim treatment had significantly fewer severe rhizoctonia lesions than the Tops MZ treatment. There were no yield differences among any of the treatments on Russet Burbank, but the untreated check consistently yielded lower in all of the yield categories.

Table 1. Plant height of Shepody potatoes as influenced by at-planting seed treatments, Ontario, Oregon, 1999.
Treatment
Application rate
Average plant height 
    inches
Tops 5.0 0.5 lb/100 lb cut seed 9.4
Tops MZ 1.0 lb/100 lb cut seed 11.0
Maxim 0.5 lb/100 lb cut seed 9.7
Blocker 10 pints/acre 8.4
Maxim + API* 1.7 DS 0.5 lb/100 lb cut seed 10.1
Tops MZ + Blocker 0.5 lb/100 lb cut seed + 10 pints/acre 10.0
Maxim + Blocker 0.5 lb/100 lb cut seed + 10 pints/acre 9.9
Untreated Check   10.0
LSD (0.05)   1.1

*API = At-Planting Insecticide

Table 2. Rhizoctonia infection in Shepody potato stems as influenced by fungicide seed treatments on September 2, Ontario, Oregon, 1999.
Treatment Application rate Stems With rhizoctonia lesions Number of Severe Rhizoctonia 
    % Lesions/10 plants
Tops 5.0 0.5 lb/100 lb cut seed 50.7 6.5
Tops MZ 1.0 lb/100 lb cut seed 46.4 3.8
Maxim 0.5 lb/100 lb cut seed 22.0 1.0
Blocker 10 pints/acre 54.8 5.0
Maxim + 

API* 1.7 DS

0.5 lb/100 lb cut seed 32.9 2.0
Tops MZ + Blocker 0.5 lb/100 lb cut seed + 10 pints/acre 28.4 2.3
Maxim + Blocker 0.5 lb/100 lb cut seed + 10 pints/acre 28.9 4.3
Untreated Check   77.0 9.8
LSD (0.05)   20.7 3.3

*API = At-Planting Insecticide

Table 3. Stem numbers as influenced by seed piece treatments, Ontario, Oregon, 1999.

Treatment
Stem number
Tops 5.0 2.5
Tops MZ 2.2
Maxim 2.3
Blocker  2.1
Maxim + API* 1.7 DS 1.9
Tops MZ + Blocker 2.0
Maxim + Blocker 2.2
Untreated Check 1.9
LSD (0.05) n.s.

*API = At Planting Insecticide

Table 4. Total yield of Shepody potatoes as influenced by seed piece treatments, Ontario, Oregon, 1999.

Treatment Total yield 
  cwt/acre
Tops 5.0  478.4
Top MZ 486.4
Maxim 506.0
Blocker 453.8
Maxim + API* 1.7 DS 483.5
Tops MZ + Blocker 503.8
Maxim + Blocker 481.3
Untreated Check 440.0
LSD (0.05) 36.3

* API = At-Planting Insecticide

Table 5. Stand count, plant height, and stem number on Russet Burbank potatoes with different seed treatments, Nyssa, Oregon, 1999.
Treatment Application

rate

Stand 

count 5/26/99

Plant height 6/4/99 Stem number 7/23/99
    50 ft of row Inches 5 plants/plot
Tops 5.0 0.5 lb/100 lb cut seed 40.0 5.9 2.7
Tops MZ 1.0 lb/100 lb cut seed 31.5 5.0 2.1
Maxim 0.5 lb/100 lb cut seed 43.0 6.5 2.3
Maxim + API* 1.7  0.5 lb/100 lb cut seed 36.8 6.2 2.5
Maxim + API* 1.5  0.5 lb/100 lb cut seed 40.5 6.6 2.9
Untreated Check   37.3 6.6 2.8
LSD (0.05)   5.3 n.s. n.s.

*API = At-Planting Insecticide

Table 6. Tuber number, tuber weight, and rhizoctonia stem incidence in Russet Burbank potatoes with different seed treatments, Nyssa, Oregon, 1999.
Treatment Ave. tuber number

(5 plants)

Total tuber weight

(5 plants)

Stems with at least 1 severe rhizoctonia lesion

(5 plants)

Stems with mild or severe rhizoctonia lesions

(5 plants)

        %
Tops 5.0  8.5 11.6 1.8 98
Tops MZ 6.5 10.7 4.0 93
Maxim 7.5 12.1 0.8 96
Maxim + API* 1.7  9.0 13.4 1.8 96
Maxim + API* 1.5 11.8 13.3 2.8 96
Untreated Check 7.5 11.5 7.3 100
LSD (.10) 2.9 n.s.   n.s.
LSD (.05)     3.1  
LSD (.01)     4.3  

*API = At-Planting Insecticide

Table 7. Effect of different seed treatments on yield of Russet Burbank potatoes, Nyssa, Oregon, 1999.
   

---------Number Ones----------

 

Total

Total

Total

Treatment >12 oz. 8–12 oz. 4–7.9 oz. # 1's # 2's yield
      -----------------------------------------cwt/acre-----------------------------
Tops 5.0 131.7 136.5 118.3 386.5 155.8 542.3
Tops MZ 150.3 110.6 93.6 354.5 166.2 520.7
Maxim 118.8 125.0 117.4 361.2 158.3 519.5
Maxim + API* 1.7 127.6 125.6 120.7 373.9 141.9 515.8
Maxim + API* 1.5 114.9 129.9 120.1 364.9 176.3 541.2
Untreated Check 117.3 111.9 96.6 325.8 140.5 466.3
  n.s. n.s. n.s. n.s. n.s. n.s.

*API = At-Planting Insecticide

Home Crops Weather Potato Blight Water Quality Irrigation Weeds Search

MES Publications, MES Notice of events, Vegetation,Malheur County, Leslie Gulch,Succor Creek,Owyhee River,Local wildlife,Strawberry Mountain, Eagle Caps

For additional information about the Malheur Agricultural Experiment Station, please send an e-mail request to:
Dr. Clinton C. Shock
Clinton.Shock@oregonstate.edu


Malheur Agricultural Experiment Station

595 Onion Avenue
Ontario, OR 97914
(541) 889-2174

FAX (541) 889-7831
 
Malheur Experiment Station Web Site Purpose and Policy OSU Home Page OSU disclaimer

Last updated  Tuesday July 30, 2002 .