Malheur Experiment Station
Oregon State University
Information for Sustainable Agriculture


SOYBEAN PERFORMANCE IN OREGON IN 1999

Erik B.G. Feibert, Clinton C. Shock, Peter Sexton,

Lamont D. Saunders, and Rhonda Bafus

Malheur Experiment Station

Oregon State University

Ontario, Oregon

Introduction

Soybean is a potentially valuable new crop for Oregon. Soybean could provide a high quality protein for animal nutrition and oil for human consumption, both of which are in short supply in the Pacific Northwest. In addition, edible or vegetable soybean production could be exported to the Orient and provide a raw material for specialized food products. Soybean is valuable as a rotation crop because of the soil-improving qualities of its residues and its N2 -fixing capability. Because of the high-value irrigated crops typically grown in the Snake River valley, soybeans may be economically feasible only at high yields.

Soybean varieties developed for the midwestern and southern states are not necessarily well adapted to Oregon’s lower night temperatures, lower relative humidity, and other climatic differences. Previous research at Ontario has shown that, compared to the commercial cultivars bred for the Midwest, plants for eastern Oregon need to have high tolerance to seed shatter and lodging, reduced plant height, increased seed set, and higher harvest index (ratio of seed to the whole plant). There is also a need to identify semi-dwarf cultivars that will grow and yield well under high seeding rates and narrow row spacing. Yields also could be increased by increasing the seeding rate from 200,000 seeds/acre to 300,000 seeds/acre if semi-dwarf lines were found adapted to local conditions.

Majid and Jolliff at OSU Corvallis identified a soybean line that would fill pods when subjected to cool night temperatures. Those lines were crossed at Corvallis with productive lines to produce OR-6 and OR-8, among others. At this point, the development moved to Ontario, OR. The later two lines were crossed at our request for several years with early-maturing, high-yielding, semi-dwarf lines by R.L. Cooper to produce semi-dwarf lines with potential adaptation to the Pacific Northwest. Selection criteria at the Malheur Experiment Station included high yield, no lodging, no shatter, low plant height, and maturity within the available growing season. In 1992, 241 single plants were selected from five F5 lines that were originally bred and selected for adaptation to eastern Oregon. Seed from these selections was planted and evaluated in 1993. A total of 18 selections were found promising and were tested further in larger plots in 1994 and 1995. From 1995 to 1998, varieties were tested using a planting rate of 300,000 seeds/acre. This report summarizes work done in 1999 as part of the continuing breeding and selection program to adapt soybeans to eastern Oregon. Some of the more promising experimental lines and some commercial lines also were tested at the Central Oregon Agricultural Research Center in Madras, Oregon in 1999.

Procedures

The 1999 line evaluation trial was conducted on a Owyhee silt loam previously planted to wheat. The herbicide Dual at 1 lb ai/acre was broadcast preplant and incorporated with a bed harrow on May 9. Seed was planted on May 18 at 200,000 seeds/acre in rows 22 inches apart. Rhizobium japonicum soil-implant inoculant was applied in the seed furrow at planting. Emergence began on May 25. The crop was furrow irrigated as necessary. Eleven of the single plant selections from 1992, nine cultivars, and OR-6 and OR-8 were planted in replicated plots four rows wide by 25 feet long in 1999. The experimental design was a randomized complete block with four replicates. All plots were cut to 22 feet.

Plant height and reproductive stage were measured weekly for each cultivar. Stand counts were made in 3 feet of row in 1996, 1997, and 1999. Prior to harvest, each plot was evaluated for lodging and seed shatter. Lodging was rated as the degree to which the plants were leaning over (0= vertical, 10= prostrate). The middle two rows in each four-row plot were harvested on October 12 using a Wintersteiger Nurserymaster small plot combine. Beans were cleaned, weighed, and oven dried to determine moisture content. Dry bean yields were corrected to 13 percent moisture. Data were analyzed by analysis of variance. Means separation was determined by the protected least significant difference test. Procedures for the Madras planting were similar except the row spacing was 24 inches and lodging was rated by a different method. Soybean was planted at Madras on May 20. A killing frost occurred on September 27.

Results and Discussion

Yields for 1999 at Ontario ranged from 27 to 54 bu/acre (Table 1). All of the 1992 single plant selections had yields greater than 40 bu/acre. All of the 1992 single plant selections had less than a 1 rating for lodging (on a scale of 0 to 10), and Minnato, Lambert, Sibley, and Vinton had a lodging rating of 3 and above. All of the 1992 single plant selections reached physiological maturity in 101 days or less. Of the 1992 single plant selections, M92-225, M92-217, M92-330, and M92-350 had seed counts sufficient for the manufacturing of tofu (< 2,270 seeds/lb) in 1999 (Table 2). The cultivars M92-217, M92-330, OR-8, Evans, and Sibley had seed counts of less than 2,270 seeds per lb every year that seed counts were made. Several lines combine early maturity, comparatively high yields, no shatter, and no lodging (Table 3). The lines M92-225 and M92-237 have light hilum color and made reasonable tofu in food quality tests in 1999.

Yields of all lines dropped starting in 1995, when the planting rate was increased from 200,000 to 300,000 seeds/acre (Table 4). The drop in yield may be due to the increase in seeding rate. A higher seeding rate could lead to a plant height increase and more lodging. In 1999, the seeding rate was reduced to 200,000 seeds per acre. However, plant populations in 1996 and 1997 were not different from 1999 (Table 5). Plant populations were below the target of 300,000 plants per acre in 1996 and 1997 and 200,000 plants per acre in 1999.

In Madras in central Oregon, all the experimental lines except M92-220 matured in time for a harvestable yield (Table 6). Of the commercial cultivars, only Agassiz and Glacier matured before a killing frost. On average yields were lower and seed sizes were smaller at Madras compared to Ontario.

Table 1. Performance of soybean cultivars, Malheur Experiment Station, Oregon State University, Ontario, Oregon, 1999.
Cultivar
Days to maturity1
Days to harvest maturity2
Lodging
Shatter
Height
Yield
Seed count
 
-- days from emergence --
0-103
percent
cm
bu/acre
seeds/lb
M92-085
94
107
0
0
76
48.6
2,455
M92-213
94
107
0
0
83
53.5
2,284
M92-217
101
107
0
0
87
47.7
2,149
M92-220
101
107
0
0
85
42.8
2,336
M92-223
101
113
0.6
0
115
39.9
2,456
M92-225
86
94
0
0
74
49.3
2,169
M92-237
94
107
0.1
0
104
44.8
2,547
M92-239
94
113
0.5
0
98
43.4
2,346
M92-314
94
113
0
0
80
47.5
2,302
M92-330
86
94
0.3
0
85
45.4
2,113
M92-350
86
101
0
0
86
42.4
2,218
OR-6
92
97
0.5
0
105
42.6
2,327
OR-8
107
113
1.6
0
110
40.1
2,223
Agassiz
94
101
0.3
0
100
43.9
2,230
Evans
101
107
0.8
0
117
40
2,187
Glacier
94
101
0.8
0
91
45.5
2,309
Gnome 85
94
101
1.3
0
107
41
2,003
Lambert
101
113
3
0
100
47.5
2,270
Minnatto
113
120
5.5
0
100
31.8
3,405
Proto
101
107
0.8
0
92
33.3
2,199
Sibley
107
113
3.5
0
110
41
2,226
Vinton
113
120
6
0
120
27.6
1,759
Mean
98
107
1.2
0
97
42.7
2,296
LSD (0.05)  
1.5
NS
 
6.8
132
1 Pods yellowing, 50 percent of leaves yellow. 
2 Stems dry enough to be combined, 95 percent of pods brown. 
3 0 = none, 10 = 100 percent lodging. 

Table 2. Seed counts for soybean cultivars for 4 years, Malheur Experiment Station, Oregon State University, Ontario, Oregon, 1999.

Cultivar
1994
1995
1996
1999
average
 
------------------------------------ seeds/lb -----------------------------------
M92-085
2,392
2,188
2,030
2,455
2,266
M92-213
2,304
1,995
2,084
2,284
2,167
M92-217
1,976
2,033
2,000
2,149
2,040
M92-220
2,660
2,213
1,974
2,336
2,296
M92-223
2,273
2,017
1,930
2,456
2,169
M92-225
2,825
2,353
2,195
2,169
2,386
M92-237
2,449
2,142
2,049
2,547
2,297
M92-239
2,041
1,946
2,227
2,346
2,140
M92-314
2,119
2,113
1,962
2,302
2,124
M92-330
2,063
2,037
2,195
2,113
2,102
M92-350
2,580
2,219
2,168
2,218
2,296
OR-6
2,803
2,205
1,985
2,327
2,330
OR-8
2,083
2,059
2,055
2,223
2,105
Agassiz
2,372
2,166
1,984
2,230
2,188
Evans
2,232
2,152
1,972
2,187
2,136
Glacier      
2,309
2,309
Gnome 85
2,463
2,167
2,040
2,003
2,168
Lambert
2,347
2,126
1,934
2,270
2,169
Minnatto      
3,405
3,405
Proto      
2,199
2,199
Sibley
2,066
1,845
1,828
2,226
1,991
Vinton      
1,759
1,759
Mean
2,336
2,110
2,034
2,296
2,194
LSD (0.05)  
155
116
132
 
Table 3. Maturity (days from emergence), lodging (0-10), and height (cm) of soybean lines, 1994 -1999, Malheur Experiment Station, Oregon State University, Ontario, Oregon, 1999.
Cultivar
1994
1995
1996
1997
1998
1999
 
Mat.
Lod.
Ht.
Mat.
Lod.
Ht.
Mat.
Lod.
Ht.
Mat.
Lod.
Ht.
Mat.
Lod.
Ht.
Mat.
Lod.
Ht.
M92-085
93
2
102
106
0
95
105
6
70
100
0
80
115
0
56
107
0
76
M92-213
107
0
70
123
0
80
105
0
80
112
0
100
128
0
70
107
0
83
M92-217
107
0
68
115
0
75
105
0
86
112
0
80
137
0
55
107
0
87
M92-220
107
4
102
123
0
80
115
2
80
112
0
85
121
0
60
107
0
85
M92-223
107
0
65
115
0
65
115
0
70
114
4
110
132
3
55
113
0.6
115
M92-225
93
5
92
106
0
80
90
1
76
100
0
60
115
0
42
94
0
74
M92-237
100
5
106
106
0
95
90
0
88
100
0
70
115
0
49
107
0.1
104
M92-239
107
0
67
106
0
55
105
0
85
112
0
65
128
0
46
113
0.5
98
M92-314
100
0
80
106
0
55
90
0
74
112
0
80
137
0
56
113
0
80
M92-330
100
1
101
98
2
95
90
0
74
100
0
65
115
0
46
94
0.3
85
M92-350
107
7
106
106
8
105
90
9
79
100
0
100
115
0
64
101
0
86
OR-6
100
9
107
106
2
100
98
9
97
112
3
85
115
8
60
97
0.5
105
OR-8
120
10
96
129
7
100
126
7
78
120
8
105
137
7
74
113
1.6
110
Agassiz
102
7
105
123
5
100
98
6
76
112
3
70
132
6
62
101
0.3
100
Evans
107
9
105
123
8
110
126
8
70
120
8
100
137
10
69
107
0.8
117
Glacier                              
101
0.8
91
Gnome 85
102
8
105
123
6
100
105
8
90
112
7
100
132
9
72
101
1.3
107
Lambert
107
9
112
129
6
85
126
7
81
112
6
105
132
9
71
113
3
100
Minnatto                              
120
5.5
100
Proto                              
107
0.8
92
Sibley
114
10
110
125
8
90
126
7
75
120
9
60
137
9
42
113
3.5
110
Vinton                              
120
6
120
Mean
104
5
94
115
3
87
106
4
79
110
3
84
127
3
58
107
1
97
Table 4. Yield of soybean cultivars in 6 years (hail depressed yields in 1998), Malheur Experiment Station, Oregon State University, Ontario, Oregon, 1999.
Cultivar
Yield
 
1994
1995
1996
1997
1998
1999
Average 1994-1997
Average 1994-1999
 
---------------------------------- bu/acre ----------------------------------
M92-085
63.3
48.7
41.2
50.0
29.4
48.6
50.8
46.9
M92-213
61.2
43.4
52.3
49.9
26.9
53.5
51.7
47.9
M92-217
35.7
49.3
48.8
55.2
25.3
47.7
47.3
43.7
M92-220
62.0
49.6
46.3
54.6
47.4
42.8
53.1
50.5
M92-223
45.6
55.3
34.5
45.5
20.9
39.9
45.2
40.3
M92-225
62.8
49.1
51.7
43.7
27.8
49.3
51.8
47.4
M92-237
63.1
50.6
42.1
48.5
31.9
44.8
51.1
46.8
M92-239
47.8
42.2
44.4
42.0
23.5
43.4
44.1
40.6
M92-314
63.2
48.9
57.8
49.2
28.6
47.5
54.8
49.2
M92-330
57.8
51.1
55.0
44.8
41.8
45.4
52.2
49.3
M92-350
63.6
55.2
43.0
49.9
34.9
42.4
52.9
48.2
OR-6
58.2
28.2
25.3
43.6
33.1
42.6
38.8
38.5
OR-8
66.3
34.0
22.1
34.2
13.6
40.1
39.2
35.1
Agassiz
62.4
36.3
38.6
46.0
21.7
43.9
45.8
41.5
Evans
68.6
13.2
14.2
29.9
25.0
40.0
31.5
31.8
Gnome 85
67.0
32.6
25.3
41.8
23.9
41.0
41.7
38.6
Lambert
69.6
31.7
29.4
53.6
35.2
47.5
46.1
44.5
Sibley
64.3
24.0
18.4
29.7
14.8
41.0
34.1
32.0

Table 5. Plant population for soybean cultivars for 3 years, Malheur Experiment Station, Oregon State University, Ontario, Oregon, 1999.

Cultivar
Plant population
 
1996
1997
1999
 
----------------------------------- plants/acre ----------------------------------
M92-085
184,533
121,664
120,780
M92-213
155,587
139,769
143,550
M92-217
72,366
153,528
92,070
M92-220
130,259
129,630
141,570
M92-223
47,038
115,870
148,500
M92-225
57,893
134,699
141,570
M92-237
47,038
134,699
145,530
M92-239
123,022
142,665
137,610
M92-314
155,587
144,114
100,980
M92-330
115,786
138,320
104,940
M92-350
173,678
137,596
132,660
OR-6
188,152
133,521
153,450
OR-8
159,205
132,527
164,340
Agassiz
155,587
118,767
111,870
Evans
94,076
127,457
103,950
Glacier    
179,190
Gnome 85
126,641
118,767
124,740
Lambert
249,663
137,596
188,100
Minnatto    
288,090
Proto    
162,360
Sibley
115,786
131,803
99,990
Vinton    
149,490
Mean
130,661
132,944
142,515
LSD (0.05)  
NS
22,361
Table 6. Performance of soybean cultivars, Central Oregon Agricultural Research Center, Oregon State University, Madras, Oregon, 1999.
Variety
Flowering date
Stage on 9/25/99 
Maturity
Yield 
Seed Size
Lodging
 
DAP*
   
bu/acre
seeds/lb
1-5**
M92-085
65
7
-
39
3,088
3.5
M92-220
67
6.5
-
-
-
-
M92-225
67
7.6
-
36
3,131
3
M92-237
62
7
-
32
3,197
3.1
M92-314
61
6.9
-
26
3,088
2.5
M92-330
72
7.7
-
41
2,441
1.8
M92-350
61
7.8
-
37
2,655
2.1
Agassiz
67
7
0
42
3,266
4.5
Evans
66
6.3
0.6
-
-
-
Glacier
69
7
0.8
37
2,735
4.3
Lambert
66
6.2
0.8
-
-
-
Minnatto
62
6.2
0.7
-
-
-
Proto
68
6.6
0.6
-
-
-
Vinton
67
5.5
1.8
-
 
-
mean  
6.8
 
35.9
2,929
3.1
LSD (0.05)  
0.4
 
7.4
 
1.7

*Day after planting

**1-5: 1= 0-20% lodged, 5= 80-100% lodged
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

Home Crops Weather Potato Blight Water Quality Irrigation Weeds Search

MES Publications, MES Notice of events, Vegetation,Malheur County, Leslie Gulch,Succor Creek,Owyhee River,Local wildlife,Strawberry Mountain, Eagle Caps

For additional information about the Malheur Agricultural Experiment Station, please send an e-mail request to:
Dr. Clinton C. Shock
Clinton.Shock@oregonstate.edu


Malheur Agricultural Experiment Station

595 Onion Avenue
Ontario, OR 97914
(541) 889-2174

FAX (541) 889-7831
 
Malheur Experiment Station Web Site Purpose and Policy OSU Home Page OSU disclaimer

Last updated  Tuesday June 28, 2011.